Home of the Help-Net Mailing List

Posting Ethics


About Help-Net
Account maintenance
posting ethics
Help-Net's archives
links to related resources
 About Help-Net
How to subscribe, unsubscribe, or change preferences
Posting ethics
Archives
Related links

In the real world, good manners are important in our relationship with the other people.
Because a mailing list is a public forum devoted to a specific topic, where hundreds, or perhaps thousands of people read every message posted to the list, it is very important to keep some measure of good manners.

Even people who are communicating in what is considered very nice and polite manner in their own culture, may be surprised to learn that messages that seem to them as fair and polite, are interpreted by others as insulting.

Not only a good will is needed on international/multicultural mailing lists such as Help-Net, but also some experience in how to behave on such mailing lists, and in what might become annoying to some readers.

There are many files which explain netiquette (net ethics).  I plan to write one myself, but until then, here are a few good documents which deal with netiquette:

* http://redtail.unm.edu/cp/netiquette.html
* http://jade.wabash.edu/wabnet/info/netiquet.htm
* http://www.netsquirrel.com/roadmap96/map07.html

While general netiquette is no more than words of wisdom coming from people who are experienced and know from that experience the consequences of many types of behaviour. On most mailing lists, some netiquette "rules" are demanded. It is very easy to ruin a good mailing list by misbehaviour.

Here are the posting instructions for Help-Net. While each of them comes for a good reason, they may look at first glance as tough.
Take them as instructions, and try to understand the reason behind each of them.

General Instructions for Posting Messages/Replies to HELP-NET

In principle, these instructions are no more than applications of general ethical rules that
should apply by default to any public mailing list.
 
  * You may feel free to post messages and questions if they are on the topic of this mailing list.  Do not, however, post messages if they are not related to the purpose of the list. Especially, do not use the mailing list for chatting, or as a place to make friends or pen-pals. 

HELP-NET is also not a proper place for solving technical problems with your PC or Win98/ME/XP, (unless they are related to the purpose of Help-Net).  A short summary of such mailing lists and resources pertaining to computer problems can be found on
http://help-net.unl.edu/hn-or.html .
 

* Help-Net is no place for commercial advertisements. On rare occasions, we might accept a posting with information about a commercial service, but this would apply only if the information is strongly related to the purpose of the list. However, In such a case, you should post the message to one of the list owners for approval prior to posting it to the list. To reach the list owners, you may use the generic address help-net-request@crcvms.unl.edu .
* The official language on Help-Net is English. Do not post messages in other languages. On the other hand, because HELP-NET is an international mailing list, it is acceptable, that the level of English would not be very high. If you wish to post a message and your English is not very good, please feel free to do so in the best you can, without the feeling the need to apologize. The important thing in such a case, is that people would be able to understand you.
* When posting a new message, it is important to use a meaningful subject line which describes the contents of the message. A good choice of a subject, helps people to follow threads (a message and all replies to it) for each topic, and help members to choose what to read and what not to read. 

Here are some common examples of bad subject choices, that you should avoid:
  1. empty subject.
  2. Subject: I need help
  3. Subject: hello
  4. Subject: a question
  5. Subject: two questions.
  6. Subject: Re: Digest ...

Although, the subject in examples 2, 4, and 5 may describe the contents of the message, they are non-informative, because most of the messages to mailing lists of Help-Net's type, fall into the category of questions and answers and providing help.
 

* Always be polite. Never publically criticize another member. If you wish to criticize, do it in a private message to the person's address. If you wish to request action by HELP-NET's list-owners, you may reach them at the generic e-mail address: help-net-request@crcvms.unl.edu

The list-owners are actively monitoring the list, and if someone's behaviour on the list is unacceptable, the list owners will act immediately. 
 

* Remember that no one on this list owes you anything. Everything on this list is on a voluntary basis, and no one is getting paid for that. This includes the list-owners/maintainers, and the list helpers/contributors. If you dislike the nature of this list, you may send us your suggestions. If it doesn't help and you still don't like it, you are free to leave the list at any time.
* When replying to a message, always think whether the reply should go to the whole list, or just to the author of the original message.
Before sending the reply, check that it does indeed go to the correct place. 
* When replying to a message, quote relevant parts from the original message so that others will see what you are responding. Do not, however quote more than is necessary.
* Do not post attachments to the list. Do not attach HTML parts to your message. If you use Microsoft's Outlook (/Outlook Express) or Netscape Messenger to post messages, you should first check that HTML and Rich Text Format (RTF) are turned off. Use only regular text format. 

In order to get more information on how to set your e-mail software to post your messages as pure text, send a message to:
LISTSERV@MAELSTROM.STJOHNS.EDU with a single line as the BODY of your message: 
  GET OWNR-FAQ.MAILCONF

Alternatively you may look at: http://nospin.com/pc/pcs05-5.html .

Another file which is even more extensive (but much bigger) is at: 
http://www.expita.com/nomime.html
 

* Do not add long signatures to your posts.  3-4 lines of signature is fine, 5-6 is acceptable, 7-8 lines is a border case. More than that is definitely improper.
* Posting or favorably referring to content that is harmful, 
threatening, abusive, preaching for hate or for harming other people, or is meant for helping in illegal activities or in harming other people, is not allowed.
* People do make mistakes, and by the very nature of Help-Net's topic, there are many Internet newbies on this list. Therefor, it is to be expected, that from time to time, someone will not follow the postings rules. The policy of the list-owners is to first send a nice private message, explaining and trying to help the poster to be aware and to learn how to follow the list rules. Only if someone persists in ignoring the rules and the messages from the list owners, will we consider taking further steps.
* For any questions or comments on the above, feel free to communicate with the owner of HELP-NET. His e-mail is:
help-net-request@crcvms.unl.edu .